PHISH jump around less
February 18, 1993 - The Dartmouth
by Brian Snyder and Gabriel Schlumberger
Album Review - Rift
"toto, I don't think we're in Oz anymore..."
Pop Phish's "Junta", "Lawnboy" or "Picture of Nectar" into your
stereo, and you suddenly find yourself transported to the "merry old
land of Oz". A Technicolor storyboard of whimsical lyrics, wonderous
energy, and lead guitarist Trey Anastasio's rollicking solos leads you
along the kaleidoscopic brick road. The latest album "Rift" draws the
house back up into the twister and deposits it once again in the black
and white world of Kansas.
The much anticipated new arrival in the
funk-rock-blues-bluegrass-wacky-neo-hippie world of Phish is a definite
departure from their previous works. Earlier albums seemed bouncy,
eclectic, and vibrant; the newest incarnation is lackluster and somber
but not without polish.
The engaging songs on previous albums break into epic jam sessions and
explore ever increasing heights of musical mastery by all four band
members. "rift" shys away from the improvisational, which constitutes
the heart of their prior work and live performances. Technically,
"Rift" is very good, exercising masterful composition and dexterous
musicianship. Vitality is the lacking ingredient.
The songs themselves are another change for Phish. Instead of
exploring new ground, the band displays a side more commonplace than on
other work. The divergent nature is particularly evident in songs such
as "Rift" and "Horn," which retain the distinctive Phish sound but are
melancholic and subdued, forgoing the frolic and hilarity associated
with previous songs.
Lacking the common strengths of Phish, two songs sound truly out of
place on this album. The band should have left "Fast Enough for You", a
mundane ballad bordering on the easy listening genre, and "my Friend,
My Friend," which resembles a Gilbert and Sullivan tune gone awry, off
of the album. The most successful new pieces - "Maze," "Sparkle" and
It's Ice"- exhibit a glimmer of the animation found in the previous
disks. "Maze" demonstrates the best Phish attributes: dramatic changes
in tempo, searing jams, and passionate wails of the guitar and bass.
"Rift" bears resemblance to the seventies rock operas of the Who and
Pink Floyd by virtue of its cohesion as an album. Unfortunately, rather
than providing more exploratory and adventerous music, Phish has spun a
disk full of psychedelic lullabies; it is at times witty and partially
inspired but, for the most part, weary and restrained.
Phish recordings are like rides at Disneyland- "Junta","Nectar", and
"Lawnboy" being Space Mountain, twisting and turning unexpectedly in an
atmosphere set ablaze with brilliance. In contrast, "Rift" is the
Teacup ride, spinning around and around in the same spot, not totally
prosaic but lacking the thrill of the others. Your prie of admission
would be best spent by riding the big roller coasters first and saving
the Teacups for later.
|
|